Did Mar author the E-VAT Law?

Mar’s enemies are clearly comfortable with twisting the truth to their advantage.

Sometimes they take credit away from him, like when they alleged that he didn’t author the law granting tax exemption to minimum wage earners. Sometimes they incorrectly attribute principal authorship to him—but for an unpopular law.

Screen Shot 2016-04-29 at 11.39.57 AM

What’s the real score?

Mar addressed this issue as early as May 2010, when during an interview with Karen Davila he categorically stated:

“I’m not the author of VAT. I’m not the sponsor of VAT.”

Mar only voted in favor of the bill, and he has been very open about that.

“Well, my view is taxes is not what’s wrong. What’s wrong is when you steal the tax. Yung pambayad sa pulis, hindi naman sa hangin nanggagaling ‘yan.”

“Kung ninanakaw ito at hindi bumabalik sa tao, ‘yan ang masama. So ang feeling ko is nirereklamo ng tao na hindi bumabalik sa kanila buwis na binabayad nila.”

Why did he vote yes? 

Here are some quotes from Mar’s explanation, taken from p. 29 of the 13th Congress’ Senate Journal No. 83, dated May 10, 2005.

“The cancer that our country is presently enduring is the cancer of a weakened financial condition… This cancer, if untreated, will result in overwhelming and widespread misery for the entire nation.”

“And so…this Representation endeavored…to draft as ideal a version of this cure as possible, so that Juan de la Cruz, while undergoing this chemotherapy, will not have to undergo inordinate pain or inordinate unnecessary cost.”

“I believe that this chemotherapy is better than if we just allow Juan de la Cruz to continue on with the cancer unabated which shall definitely lead to his demise.”

Journal No. 83_13th Congress_10 May 2005 [Page 29]

So it’s clear: Mar believed that the measure was for the good of the nation.

Where’s the proof he didn’t author the bill?

The committee report lists Senator Recto as the sponsor, and Senators Drilon, Flavier, Pangilinan, and Gordon as the other authors.

CR 16 on VAT_13th Congress_7 March 2005 [Page 2]

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s